Physical Address
304 North Cardinal St.
Dorchester Center, MA 02124
Physical Address
304 North Cardinal St.
Dorchester Center, MA 02124
We live in an age of incredible speed, especially when it comes to PC storage. NVMe SSDs on the PCIe interface fundamentally changed how fast our computers feel compared to older SATA drives. Building on that foundation, PCIe Gen 4 SSDs became the gold standard, offering fantastic performance for gamers and professionals alike. Now, the next leap is here: PCIe Gen 5 SSDs are flooding the market, promising theoretical read and write speeds nearly double those of their Gen 4 predecessors – pushing well beyond 10,000 MB/s in many SSD speed tests.
But does that headline-grabbing potential translate into a real-world difference you’ll feel? With Gen 5 SSDs commanding significantly higher prices and often generating substantial heat, the crucial question every PC builder and upgrader faces in 2025 is: Is Gen 5 SSD worth it? Or, put another way, is PCIe 5.0 SSD noticeable for gaming or everyday tasks compared to the already blazing-fast performance of a good PCIe Gen 4 SSD?
Many users wonder: “What is the real world speed difference between Gen 4 and Gen 5 SSD?” or “Does Gen 5 SSD make games load faster?”. Forget claims based purely on synthetic benchmarks; at Comparisonmath.com, we believe in testing what truly matters. We’ve put top-tier Gen 4 vs Gen 5 SSD drives head-to-head in practical scenarios – measuring OS boot times, application startup speeds, critical SSD game loading times, and large file transfer speeds.
Our goal is to cut through the hype and provide a clear, data-driven answer to whether the considerable investment in a Gen 5 NVMe SSD makes sense today for most people, or if sticking with the proven value and performance of the best NVMe SSDs in the established Gen 4 market is the smarter choice. Let’s find out if this latest speed upgrade truly moves the needle.
Okay, let’s lay the technical groundwork, explaining the key differences between the PCIe generations relevant to NVMe SSDs and why theoretical speeds don’t always tell the full story.
Before comparing benchmark results, it’s helpful to understand why PCIe Gen 5 SSDs promise more speed than PCIe Gen 4 SSDs. The difference lies primarily in the underlying data highway they use – the Peripheral Component Interconnect Express (PCIe) bus – and how the NVMe protocol leverages it.
NVMe (Non-Volatile Memory Express) is a communication protocol built specifically for modern flash-based storage (SSDs). Unlike the older AHCI protocol designed for spinning hard drives, NVMe minimizes latency and maximizes parallelism, allowing SSDs to communicate much more directly and efficiently with the CPU over the PCIe bus. This is why even older NVMe SSDs feel significantly faster than SATA SSDs.
The PCIe bus is made up of several data lanes. Most M.2 NVMe SSDs use four PCIe lanes (written as “x4”). The key difference between Gen 4 vs Gen 5 SSD performance lies in the bandwidth each PCIe lane provides per generation:
This substantial increase in raw throughput is the core technical advantage highlighted when discussing PCIe 5.0 vs 4.0 SSD performance.
While the leap from ~8 GB/s to ~16 GB/s theoretical bandwidth is impressive, it primarily impacts sequential read/write speeds – transferring large, single files (like huge video files). This is what most synthetic SSD speed tests (like CrystalDiskMark sequential Q8T1) measure and what manufacturers advertise prominently.
However, much of the perceived “snappiness” of a system – OS boot times, application loading, responsiveness during multitasking – relies more heavily on random read/write performance at low queue depths and low latency (often measured as Random 4K Q1T1 IOPS or MB/s). These operations involve accessing many small files scattered across the drive. While Gen 5 SSDs also improve here over Gen 4, the gains are proportionally much smaller than the doubling seen in sequential speeds. Furthermore, other system components (CPU processing the data, RAM speed, software efficiency) often become the bottleneck long before even a fast Gen 4 SSD reaches its absolute random I/O limits in everyday tasks.
One technology often mentioned alongside faster SSDs is Microsoft’s DirectStorage API. Its goal is to allow the GPU to directly access game assets from a fast NVMe SSD, bypassing the CPU for decompression and reducing overhead. This could significantly speed up SSD game loading times and enable more complex game worlds by better utilizing the high bandwidth of NVMe drives.
However, DirectStorage requires game developers to specifically implement it. While adoption is slowly growing, few titles currently leverage it extensively, and even fewer show dramatic loading time improvements directly correlated solely to Gen 5 SSD speeds over fast Gen 4. So, asking “Will DirectStorage make Gen 5 SSDs worth it?” remains largely speculative for now. Its future potential is interesting, but it doesn’t dramatically impact the Gen 4 vs Gen 5 SSD value proposition today.
Okay, let’s specify the drives we compared and outline precisely how we tested them to assess the real-world difference between Gen 4 vs Gen 5 SSD performance.
To make a meaningful comparison between mature PCIe Gen 4 technology and the cutting-edge PCIe Gen 5 standard, we selected popular, high-performance drives representing each generation. Our methodology focused on practical, repeatable tests that reflect common user experiences, rather than solely relying on synthetic benchmarks that often don’t show the full picture of NVMe Gen 4 vs Gen 5 benchmark results in daily use.
To ensure a fair fight within the high-performance segment of each generation, we used the following 2TB capacity drives:
Note: Both drives were updated to their latest firmware versions before testing and were tested as secondary drives (containing OS, games, and applications being tested) to ensure consistency.
We used a modern, high-end test system capable of fully supporting both PCIe Gen 4 and Gen 5 M.2 speeds, ensuring the platform itself wasn’t a bottleneck:
Our goal was to directly answer questions like “Is PCIe 5.0 SSD noticeable for gaming?” and “What is the real-world speed difference between Gen 4 and Gen 5 SSD?”. We prioritized tests reflecting everyday use:
All tests involving timing were performed multiple times (at least 3-5 runs per scenario), with outliers discarded and results averaged to ensure reliability. Drives were allowed cool-down periods between intense tests. Standard procedures like TRIM commands were allowed to run between tests to maintain consistent performance.
With this methodology, we aimed for a practical assessment of the real-world Gen 5 SSD speed test difference compared to a top-tier Gen 4 drive.
Okay, let’s dive into the core findings. How did the blistering theoretical speeds of the PCIe Gen 5 SSD stack up against the high-performing PCIe Gen 4 SSD in our real-world tests? The results might surprise you if you only look at the marketing numbers.
This is where the rubber meets the road. We took our Crucial T700 (Gen 5) and WD_BLACK SN850X (Gen 4) drives and put them through the practical scenarios outlined earlier. Here’s a breakdown of the Gen 4 vs Gen 5 SSD real-world speed difference we observed:
This is often the most anticipated potential benefit, directly addressing “Does Gen 5 SSD make games load faster?” and “Is PCIe 5.0 SSD noticeable for gaming?”.
Here, we finally saw the theoretical potential of PCIe 5.0 vs 4.0 SSD performance translate into measurable gains, but with caveats.
Okay, let’s address the practical realities of integrating a potentially high-speed, high-heat component like a PCIe Gen 5 SSD into a system, comparing it to the more established PCIe Gen 4 SSDs.
Beyond raw performance numbers, the practical aspects of running a Gen 4 vs Gen 5 SSD are crucial. Particularly with Gen 5 drives, managing heat and ensuring platform compatibility are key considerations often overlooked amidst the speed hype.
One of the most significant talking points surrounding PCIe Gen 5 SSDs is their thermal output. Doubling the bandwidth and pushing controllers and NAND flash harder generates substantially more heat.
This is a critical factor often missed: You can’t just plug a PCIe Gen 5 SSD into any motherboard and expect full speed.
All right, let’s talk about the dollars and sense. Performance and features are important, but the price tag often dictates the final decision. How does the value of a cutting-edge PCIe Gen 5 SSD compare to a proven PCIe Gen 4 SSD in the current market?
Speed claims and benchmarks aside, the decision between Gen 4 vs Gen 5 SSD technology frequently boils down to cost-effectiveness. Do the performance benefits of Gen 5 justify the often significant extra expense and practical considerations like heat management?
This is the core question we need to answer, based on our real-world testing:
Based on the current landscape (as of 2025), the target user who genuinely benefits from paying the premium for a PCIe Gen 5 SSD is typically:
For the average gamer, student, home office user, or even most content creators, the tangible benefits do not yet outweigh the substantial cost and heat management requirements.
Okay, let’s conclude the article, summarizing our findings and providing a clear recommendation based on the real-world testing and value assessment of Gen 4 vs Gen 5 SSD technology.
The race for storage speed has brought us to the era of PCIe Gen 5 SSDs, boasting staggering theoretical performance figures. But after putting these cutting-edge drives head-to-head against mature, high-performance PCIe Gen 4 SSDs in practical, real-world tests, our findings are conclusive.
For the vast majority of PC users – including gamers, home users, students, and most content creators – our recommendation for 2025 is clear: NO, a PCIe Gen 5 SSD is generally not worth the significant extra cost and hassle right now.
Stick with a high-quality PCIe Gen 4 NVMe SSD. Drives like the WD_BLACK SN850X, Samsung 980 Pro/990 Pro, Crucial P5 Plus, and others offer fantastic real-world performance that already feels instantaneous for most tasks. They run cooler, are more affordable, and don’t require specific motherboard slots beyond standard M.2 Gen 4 compatibility. You get virtually all the perceivable speed benefits for considerably less money, making the best PCIe Gen 4 SSD value proposition significantly stronger.
The only users who might currently justify the premium for a Gen 5 SSD are professionals whose daily workflow involves the constant transfer or manipulation of exceptionally large (multi-hundred GB) sequential files, where even shaving minutes off transfers provides a direct productivity or financial benefit. For everyone else, it falls firmly into the category of “early adopter” technology with bragging rights potential but little practical advantage.
While technologies like DirectStorage aim to better utilize faster SSD bandwidth for gaming, its widespread adoption and tangible impact are still developing. It’s possible future games could benefit more, but buying a premium Gen 5 drive today based on that speculation is likely unwise. By the time DirectStorage is truly transformative (if it becomes so), Gen 5 drives may be cheaper, cooler, and even faster.
Don’t get caught up solely in the headline sequential numbers. Focus on the tasks you perform. For nearly every consumer PC user in 2025, a reliable, fast PCIe Gen 4 NVMe SSD provides the best NVMe SSD value and an experience that is virtually indistinguishable from current Gen 5 drives in everyday use. Save your money, enjoy blazing-fast Gen 4 speeds, and avoid the extra heat and cost until PCIe Gen 5 technology matures and offers truly compelling real-world benefits for the average user.
Based on current testing (as of 2025), no, the speed difference offered by PCIe 5.0 SSDs is generally not noticeable for gaming. Game loading times are usually only fractions of a second faster, if at all, compared to a high-end PCIe Gen 4 drive. Other system components and game engine limitations often prevent games from fully utilizing Gen 5 speeds today.
Our tests show that Gen 5 SSDs typically do not make games load significantly faster than fast Gen 4 SSDs. Any measured difference is usually less than a second and imperceptible in actual gameplay. Technologies like DirectStorage aim to improve this in the future, but the impact is minimal in most currently available games.
The biggest real-world speed difference is seen in large sequential file transfers (e.g., copying a single huge video file), where Gen 5 drives can be significantly faster due to their higher peak throughput. However, for everyday tasks like booting Windows, launching applications, and loading games, which rely more on random access, the real-world speed difference is often negligible and not noticeable compared to a high-performance Gen 4 drive.
Gen 5 SSDs generate significantly more heat than Gen 4 drives due to their higher speeds and power draw. While perhaps not “too hot” if properly managed, they require robust cooling solutions (large heatsinks) to prevent thermal throttling (slowing down due to heat). Running them without adequate cooling can lead to poor performance and potentially reduced lifespan.
Yes, absolutely. Due to their high heat output, using a substantial heatsink is mandatory for PCIe Gen 5 NVMe SSDs to maintain their performance and operate safely. Many Gen 5 drives come with large heatsinks included, or you must use a capable heatsink provided with your motherboard’s M.2 slot.
For the vast majority of users (including gamers and general productivity users) in 2025, it is currently not worth upgrading from a high-performance Gen 4 NVMe SSD to a Gen 5 model. The real-world performance gains are minimal for typical tasks, while the cost is significantly higher and heat management is more demanding. Stick with your fast Gen 4 drive unless you have very specific professional needs involving constant large file transfers.
The main current point of PCIe 5.0 SSDs is to achieve the absolute maximum sequential data transfer speeds possible. This primarily benefits professionals who work with extremely large files and can save significant time during transfers. For typical consumer use, the point is less about practical benefit today and more about adopting the newest technology standard, which may become more relevant in the future as software evolves (e.g., potential with DirectStorage).
It’s possible that future games heavily utilizing DirectStorage could benefit more from the higher bandwidth of Gen 5 SSDs, potentially making them more “worth it” down the line. However, based on current game implementations and performance data, DirectStorage alone does not yet justify the premium cost and heat of Gen 5 SSDs over fast Gen 4 drives for gaming today.
Modern high-end motherboards typically provide separate PCIe 5.0 lanes for the main GPU slot (x16) and at least one M.2 slot (x4), usually direct from the CPU. So, you don’t typically have to choose – a compatible motherboard allows both a PCIe 5.0 capable GPU and a PCIe 5.0 SSD to operate at their respective full speeds simultaneously. However, always check the specific motherboard’s specifications regarding lane allocation. While current GPUs don’t need PCIe 5.0 bandwidth yet, a Gen 5 SSD needs a PCIe 5.0 M.2 slot to reach its full potential.
If you install a PCIe Gen 5 SSD into a motherboard slot that only supports PCIe Gen 4 (or Gen 3), the SSD will still work, but it will operate at the maximum speed of that slot. It will essentially function as a fast Gen 4 (or Gen 3) drive. You will not get the benefit of the higher Gen 5 speeds you paid for, but it is backward compatible.
Yes, generally Gen 5 SSDs tend to consume slightly more power under load compared to Gen 4 SSDs. This is necessary to fuel the faster controller and NAND flash operating at higher speeds. While the difference might not dramatically impact your overall system power draw, it contributes to the higher heat output observed with Gen 5 drives.
The PlayStation 5 (PS5) currently supports PCIe Gen 4 NVMe SSDs for storage expansion. It does not support PCIe Gen 5 speeds. Therefore, installing a Gen 5 SSD in a PS5 will make it run only at Gen 4 speeds, offering no advantage over a high-quality Gen 4 drive. For the PS5, a good PCIe Gen 4 SSD meeting Sony’s requirements (speed, heatsink) is the best and most cost-effective choice.
The lifespan (endurance) of an SSD is typically measured in Terabytes Written (TBW) and isn’t directly tied solely to its PCIe generation (Gen 4 vs Gen 5). Both Gen 4 and Gen 5 drives come with varying TBW ratings depending on the model, capacity, and quality of NAND flash used. While Gen 5 drives might run hotter (potentially impacting long-term component health if not cooled properly), their fundamental NAND endurance ratings are generally comparable to high-end Gen 4 drives of similar capacity. Always check the manufacturer’s specified TBW rating for the specific model you are considering.
To check if your motherboard supports a Gen 5 SSD at full speed, you need to look at its specifications. Specifically, check:
1. Does it have an M.2 slot that explicitly states support for “PCIe 5.0 x4”?
2. Does the motherboard chipset and your CPU support PCIe 5.0 lanes for storage? (Generally AMD Ryzen 7000 series + B650E/X670/X670E or Intel 12th Gen+ + Z790/certain B760 boards).
Consult your motherboard’s manual or product page; compatibility is crucial.
No. If you install a PCIe Gen 4 SSD into a motherboard’s PCIe Gen 5 capable M.2 slot, the drive will still only operate at its maximum Gen 4 speed. The slot being Gen 5 capable doesn’t magically make a Gen 4 drive faster. It just means the slot has the potential bandwidth for a Gen 5 drive.